Showing posts with label Favourite movies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Favourite movies. Show all posts

Saturday, 1 August 2026

2000-2025 - A Quarter Century of Film Favourites

Cinema established itself as the art form of the 20th century and, despite the rise of TV, remained a dominant force in entertainment and popular culture throughout. But what of the past twenty-five years, with its technological shifts and renewed challenges from other media? I'll get into the highs and lows of cinema's recent history some other time. For now, here are some thoughts on my favourite films - one for each year of the century so far - hopefully illustrating that the medium is still tolerably healthy.

Okay, rules... I've made one definitive pick for each year, even when several films feel equal in my affection. All choices are based on the UK release schedule. And yes, I'm starting with the year 2000 - even though technically speaking it rounded off the 20th century - because it's the first recent year to start with a 2. I'm making no big proclamations about all these films being the best/most influential/most important... They're just (currently and therefore subject to change) the films I like most.

Here goes. 

2000 - Magnolia

(Honorable Mention - O Brother, Where Art Thou?)

With a UK release in early 2000, Magnolia now feels like the end of the 1990s for me - representing the grown-up, challenging, and innovative cinema that made that my preferred movie decade. This kaleidoscope of human flouderings and failings is to date my favourite film of all time and an example of what I once labelled here as an 'imperfect 10'. Any shortcomings and nitpicks stem from the bold, adventurous nature of Paul Thomas Anderson's storytelling. The way the camera, the editing, and the score weave a clutch of intimate human stories into a meaningful whole never fails to impress me. Plus, it includes my most loved performances of Tom Cruise (whose portrait of a misogynist self-help guru now seems scarily prescient), John C. Reilly (as a well-meaning cop in love with the wrong person), and the late, lamented Philip Seymour Hoffman (effectively playing an angel in human form). Plus there's the way Anderson incorporates the songs of Aimee Mann. And a climax of literally Biblical proportions.

2001 - Moulin Rouge!

(Honorable Mention - Mulholland Drive)

How wonderful life is with this - Baz Luhrmann's third feature - in the world. The Aussie filmmaker's tale of love between a poet and a courtesan during Paris's Belle Epoque is wildly silly and occasionally cringing (I'm thinking of you, 'Elephant Love Medley'), but overall feels nothing short of rapturous. Luhrmann reinvented the concept of the movie musical with his anachronistic use of Elton John and Madonna tunes in a late 19th-century setting, while overpowering audiences using his dizzying visual style. The way he can flip from comic to romantic to tragic on a French centime is, for me, unsurpassed, never more so than during the song (It's a little bit funny...) with which Christian wins Satine's heart. Intoxicating, hilarious, heartbreaking.

2002 - Minority Report

(Honorable Mention - Memento; Monsoon Wedding)

Steven Spielberg has directed seventeen films this side of 2000, and this is up there with the very best. Minority Report does all the things I love about speculative science fiction and does them well. The extrapolation of contemporary technology to create a convincing future world, one that's coloured in with Blade Runner levels of detail (only much shinier)... The exploration of an intriguing moral conundrum - specifically, what if you could predict and therefore prosecute crimes before they actually took place? And reflection on the era in which the futuristic film is made. It's all here in a narrative powered by the director at the peak of his technical prowess. From the moment Tom Cruise's Pre-Crime detective falls foul of the technology he operates, the film barely pauses for breath, while remaining totally coherent throughout. It also boasts a typically great support performance from Samantha Morton as 'pre-cog' Agatha. Pure entertainment.

2003 - The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King

(Honorable Mention - City of God)

Let me be honest here and subvert my own rules if only slightly. My favourite films for this year and the previous two were the episodes of Peter Jackson's phenomenal The Lord of the Rings trilogy. But similar to what the US Film Academy did at the next year's Oscars, I'm letting The Return of the King represent the entire hobbity project, thereby giving other movies deserved room to shine. Basically, the Rings films are the ones I've watched the most in my life. Jackson and his co-creatives didn't just climb the mountain of J. R. R. Tolkien's gargantuan text, they carved it out, creating something as beautiful as it was epic. The results filled me with joy and gave me some of the greatest theatrical experiences of my life. (I watched all three at the cinema with my completely enthralled dad). They're precious memories, and indeed precious box sets, full of moments both intimate and sweeping. And despite the production team's experimentation with CGI, much of these films still feel gratifyingly solid in a way that the subsequent Hobbit trilogy frequently did not. With the 25th anniversary of The Fellowship of the Ring on the horizon, it's definitely time for a rewatch.

2004 - Shaun of the Dead

(Honorable Mention - Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind)

There's a lovely story told on the Shaun of the Dead Blu-ray of an unimpressed supporting artist (that's 'extra' in old-school phraseology) mistaking Simon Pegg for a crew member and commenting, "Straight to video, this one". The observer in question was no doubt deceived by the production's modest £4 million budget and steadily recycled hoard of undead shamble-ons. What they couldn't envisage was how Edgar Wright's ginsu-sharp editing would shape his and Pegg's loving homage to the zombie genre into one of the best British films of the decade, kick-starting their now-famed 'Three Flavours Cornetto Trilogy' (more of which later). Both hilarious comedy and legit horror, Shaun is far better than anything that might be labelled 'spoof'. It's a love letter to George A. Romero (Night of the Living Dead), a love story, a spot-on satire of Gen-X slacker culture, the first of multiple Simon Pegg/Nick Frost on-screen bromances, and one of those films that, should you stumble on it while channel-hopping late at night, you'll inevitably watch to the end. How's that for a slice of fried gold?

2005 - King Kong

(Honorable Mention - The Aviator)

It's another Peter Jackson production. (Call me a PJ fanboy, and I'll wear that t-shirt with pride.) Speaking once more of love-letters, this remake of the most iconic ape movie in cinema history is a homage to every aspect of Merian C. Cooper's 1933 original. Having lovingly recreated Depression-era New York and sailed his band of ill-prepared Tinseltown adventurers into the fogs of Kong Island, Jackson takes his audience on one of the modern era's most exhilarating cinematic theme-park rides. What makes this movie so memorable, however, is the reframing of the Kong/Ann Darrow story, establishing a heart-rending, empathetic bond between standard-sized woman and gigantic primate. It makes for less screaming from the radiant Naomi Watts and more sobbing from the audience, once Kong falls prey to human greed. You don't yell in fear of the 25-foot ape as he breaks free; you damn well cheer him on, right to that final, fateful showdown atop the Empire State Building. Such a shame beauty and this beast didn't have more time together.

2006 - Little Miss Sunshine

(Honorable Mentions - Children of Men; Pan's Labyrinth)

Some choices are brutal. I mean, look at those honourable mentions. Any one of these three films earns a spot on my favourite-films-of-all-time list - this was one hella good year! But, finally, I've gone with the one that I've watched (and that warms my heart) the most. It's a narrative miracle that a story beginning with so much familial dysfunction, self-harm, and skewed thinking can end in a place of such deep, anarchic joy, especially given the sequence of disasters that occur along the way. But that's why the Hoovers are my favourite movie family of all time (apologies to the Addamses and the Von Trapps). With its deeply sardonic sense of humour, a handful of rich character performances, and the funniest vehicle ever to complete a movie road trip (apologies to Herbie and Jake and Elwood's Bluesmobile), Little Miss Sunshine never fails to make me grin while feeling better about the whole human experience. And its wisdom is eternal: better to lose with style than never to try at all.

2007 - Zodiac

(Honorable Mention - Hot Fuzz)

It takes a skilled director (and indeed, skilled writers) to take a true-crime story, where the crimes in question were never resolved, and turn it into a satisfying thriller. But that's what David Fincher does with the story - not so much of San Francisco's notorious Zodiac killer, but of the obsession of those trying to catch him. It's a Ruffolo/Downey Jr/Gyllenhaal triple whammy, and they're all at their best as three very different men trying to crack the case, along with John Carroll Lynch in his creepy supporting turn as suspect Arthur Leigh Allen. Those expecting the horrors of Fincher's harrowing Se7en get something much more purely psychological, as the killer's madness infects those in his pursuit. A taut script with direction to match, plus David Shire's eerie score, make this one of Fincher's best.

2008 - There Will Be Blood

(Honorable Mentions - The Dark Knight; WALL-E)

I didn't know what to make of this much-lauded Paul Thomas Anderson film, the first time I saw it. It was such a far cry from Magnolia (see above) that I felt something akin to let down. But you've got to respect a director who can reinvent his own style as completely as this. Subsequent viewings have confirmed for me what a tour de force this is, with its masterful cinematography, vivid recreation of the early 20th-century California oil fields, and barnstorming performances by both Daniel Day-Lewis and (suck it, Quentin Tarantino) Paul Dano. Playing two very different types of self-made man in a world of capitalist excess, the escalating rivalry between them is raw, unfiltered, and totally mesmerising. It's a film deeply admired by Christopher Nolan, whose work resembles There Will Be Blood in its scope and commitment to in-camera effects. But more of that later...

2009 - Slumdog Millionaire

(Honorable Mention - Up)

I went to an advanced screening of this one with my pal Jen, and it knocked us both out with its pace, its verve, and its originality. Then we laughed later about posters hyping it as 'the feel-good movie of the year'. This story of a young man's attempt to reconnect with his lost love through appearing on India's Who Wants to Be a Millionaire deals with police torture, race murder, and child mutilation among other delights before delivering on any of the promised good feelings. That it succeeds in carrying its audience through such dark times is thanks to the screenplay's magical realism (this is a tale all about destiny), Danny Boyle's thrilling direction, and an invigorating score by A. R. Rahman. The film made a movie star out of Dev Patel, in a foolishly optimistic but undeniably compelling love story that drags you through the emotional wringer before plastering a smile all over your tired face.

2010 - The Social Network

(Honorable Mention - Inception)

David Fincher again. It says a lot about his style, I think, that my favourite film of his doesn't deal with serial killers (real-life or fictional) or bare-knuckle organisations you don't talk about. The creation of a social media site, however iconic, didn't seem to promise great cinema - but put a script by The West Wing's Aaron Sorkin into Fincher's hands, and you get a result every bit as dynamic as Se7en or Fight Club. Sorkin's writing shapes the story of how Mark Zuckerberg launched Facebook into a fast-talking study of friendship and betrayal, and Fincher's crisp direction matches the dialogue beat for beat. Jesse Eisenberg is cast perfectly as the website's co-creator, his character journey compelling and rich with complexity, but it's Andrew Garfield who supplies the story's heart as best friend and Facebook co-founder Eduardo Saverin. It's sharp, witty, and endlessly quotable, and the soundtrack by Messrs Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross doesn't hurt either. That Sorkin has taken over directorial reins and is bringing us 'spiritual sequel' The Social Reckoning later this year is reason for much celebration.

2011 - True Grit

(Honorable Mention - Bridesmaids)

Yes, I know that the Coen Brothers' other literary adaptation - No Country for Old Men - received all the plaudits, landing them a trio of well-deserved Oscars, but my preference is for this one. Maybe it's because of their dark take on the source material, Charles Portis' 1968 novel, or maybe because the characters allow them to be a bit more 'Coens-y' than in No Country. It could be due to the Brothers' reunion with the Dude himself, Jeff Bridges, in the role of Deputy U. S. Marshall Rooster Cogburn on which John Wayne put his stamp in 1969. (Don't take me down with a Colt revolver, but I prefer Bridges' performance.) Or perchance it's the chemistry between the leads, with Matt Damon playing against type as puffed-up Texas Ranger Le Boeuf (his preferred pronunciation 'Le Beef'), and a 14-year-old Hailee Steinfeld as precocious and vengeful Mattie Ross. Ultimately, I think it's because this True Grit is truer to the novel and truly representative of the western genre, while retaining a true Coen feel. Along with a lot of grit.


2012 - Moonrise Kingdom

(Honorable Mention - Skyfall)

Director/writer/creator Wes Anderson inspires both love and hate from the film community. I'm in a position where I frequently feel the love but can appreciate the reasons behind the hate - sometimes his showy cleverness and theatricality are just too much. For me, Moonrise Kingdom and its follow-up The Grand Budapest Hotel pitch it just right in terms of content and style. Both are beautifully crafted shaggy-dog stories, and Moonrise has an especial charm along with genuine hilarity, telling as it does a unique coming-of-age story between a rebellious, book-loving girl and a runaway Boy Scout. Aside from its engaging 13-year-old leads, it has the usual gallery of deliciously deadpan adult performances (Bill Murray, Tilda Swinton, Ed Norton, etc. etc). A particular delight, however, is Bruce Willis fully embracing the Anderson method along with clear-frame retro glasses, as Police Captain Sharp. Charming from start to meticulously crafted finish, this is one to wholeheartedly love.


2013 - The World's End

(Honorable Mention - The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug)

Of the films making up the Wright/Pegg 'Cornetto Trilogy', The World's End is sometimes viewed as the slightly disappointing final entry. Not in my book. If Shaun of the Dead is the most heartfelt and Hot Fuzz the funniest, then The World's End is the smartest of the trio. It's also significantly more mature than the others in its central conceit - a group of middle-aged friends are cajoled into re-attempting a legendary pub crawl from their teen years by the one member who's never moved on, thus testing (like Jay Gatsby) whether you can repeat the past. And that's before the big genre twist thirty minutes in. What I love about this film is how even when events take an apocalyptic turn, the pub crawl and all it signifies for Simon Pegg's tragicomic Gary King remains the spine of the story. The central ensemble is great value, totally convincing as a group of estranged school friends in various gradations of drunkenness. Plus, the flipping of the established comic/straight-man roles (Nick Frost this time acting as Pegg's foil) works a treat. Don't let anyone tell you otherwise - this film wraps up the ice-cream-flecked project just perfectly.


2014 - The Babadook

(Honorable Mention - Dawn of the Planet of the Apes; The Grand Budapest Hotel)

The term 'elevated horror' emerged around this time, expressly to describe films like this one. It's the kind of horror that rejects jump scares and gore in favour of unsettling ambience and smart, psychological concepts to cultivate fear. The first feature of Australian writer/director Jennifer Kent, The Babadook is one of the best-crafted and most rewatchable of the 'elevated' sub-genre. Essie Davis gives a magnificent performance as struggling single mother Amelia, whose latent resentment towards her own child (an unholy terror named Samuel) may or may not be manifesting as the terrifying creature of the title. Mister Babadook himself is straight out of a German Expressionist nightmare, and is all the more scary for the mere fleeting glimpses we see of him. A masterclass in slowly mounting dread, this is also a clever and psychologically coherent study in toxic parent-child dynamics that muddies the waters regarding who is driving who mad. The movie also includes the most disturbing child's pop-up book in the history of fiction. If it's in a word, or it's in a look, you can't get rid of...


2015 - Whiplash

(Honorable Mentions - Mad Max: Fury Road; The Martian)

Director Damien Chazelle would achieve mainstream success two years later with the much-feted La La Land, but many cinephiles rate this film as his best to date. Whiplash is not what you might expect from its 'talented young jazz drummer goes to music school' premise. The main difference is J. K. Simmons' Oscar-bagging performance as Terence Fletcher, a band instructor whose pursuit of excellence in his students incorporates emotional and sometimes physical abuse. It's more Marine Corps boot camp than music conservatory, and the twisted dynamic between Miles Teller's protégé and his mentor/nemesis is pure electricity throughout. Chazelle shoots this drama as a thriller, and the coaching sequences will have you clawing the sofa cushions they're so stress-inducing. The director has revisited the movie's core theme - the heavy price of ambition - since then, but never with as much heart-racing intensity. 


2016 - Sing Street

(Honorable Mention - Arrival)

I enjoy the work of Dublin-born musician-turned-filmmaker John Carney. He doesn't make musicals, he makes dramas about music - the people who write it and play it and produce it and succeed or fail at it, who fall in love with it and to it and who try to make their living from it... I love all his films, but none quite so much as I love Sing Street. His story of Conor, a lad growing up in 1980s Dublin who starts a band to impress a girl and to survive life in the school from hell, is one of the best coming-of-age narratives I've ever experienced. Original songs punctuate the film, each paying note-perfect homage to a musical genre of the era, while Conor and his friends undergo a style and character evolution that's both funny and charming. It's touching as a romance, a bromance, and a tale of brotherly love, while never shying away from the tougher aspects of teenage life. Endlessly rewatchable, this is - despite its heartfelt tribute to the '80s - a music movie for the ages.


2017 - Paddington 2

(Honorable Mentions - Moonlight; Dunkirk; Get Out)

Okay, bear with me. That's one heavyweight list of honourable mentions - I even placed two of them above my current choice on my favourite films list for 2017. But time and repeated viewings provide greater perspective, and I'm ready to die on the hill that says Paddington 2 is among the greatest films of the 21st century. And if you don't believe me, see what Pedro Pascal has to say in The Unbearable Weight of Massive Talent: 'I cried through the entire thing. It made me want to be a better man.' I can't say I wept, exactly, but I found this film massively endearing and funny throughout. I've never seen a family film made with greater craft and attention to detail, nor have I seen one more attuned to the needs of the moment, with its message on the simple power of kindness. Sweet and sharp as the tang of an artisan orange marmalade, this is what happens when you make a child-friendly film with the care and passion of a Scorsese, a del Toro, or an Anderson (specifically Wes). It's like joy in a jar.


2018 - First Man

(Honorable Mentions - The Shape of Water; Avengers: Infinity War; Mission: Impossible - Fallout)

Space travel movies appeal to me, and this one I find especially potent, based as it is on real events - those heady days of the Apollo program, where the sky was no longer the limit, and the cosmos had become the final frontier. Ryan Gosling is Neil Armstrong, stoic to a fault as the eponymous first man on the moon, with Claire Foy as his supportive yet far from meek wife Janet. The adventure and wonder of space travel is powerfully conveyed along with the height of its stress levels and its stakes. Writer Josh Singer's narrative has dynamism and grit, and Justin Hurwitz's rhapsodic score fuels the story the way liquid hydrogen fuelled Apollo 11 (I looked it up). There's also a sadness that permeates the film, not least because of the family tragedy Armstrong carries deep within him. First Man cemented the critical reputation that Damien Chazelle had built with Whiplash and La La Land. And while it proved a box office disappointment (along with his subsequent grand folly Babylon), at least it shot for the moon creatively speaking.

2019 - Once Upon a Time in... Hollywood

(Honorable Mention - Avengers: Endgame)

Just when I thought I was never going to love another Quentin Tarantino film quite as much as Pulp Fiction, along came this one - his extended love-letter to the cinema of 1960s Hollywood. Leonardo DiCaprio gives a top-tier performance as action star Rick Dalton, whose career is fading along with Hollywood's Golden Age, while Brad Pitt has never been cooler in his role as Rick's stunt-double and loyal friend Cliff Booth. Meanwhile, Margot Robbie represents the doomed innocence of the cinematic era in her role as equally doomed Sharon Tate - although maybe not, with Tarantino in charge of her story... It's a sprawling and loquacious tale (as you'd expect), but what makes it stand out is how steeped it is in a specific kind of nostalgia - 1969 painstakingly crafted through the lens of the filmmaker's memory. Rick's endeavours to recapture a moment of his former glory on a TV shoot have both hilarity and pathos, while Cliff's odyssey into the home of the Manson Family is quietly chilling. As for the finale - it's perfectly set up, brutal, and brilliant. Plus, the QT needle-drops have never worked better. More real-world grounded (for the most part) than the auteur's other work, this is an immersive and often outrageous tribute to a bygone entertainment world.

2020 - Parasite

(Honorable Mention - 1917)

1917 was the first title that I scored as 10 on this blog, so it was going to take quite some film to beat it as my favourite of that year. Parasite is that film. As a satire on wealth inequality, it's tough to match, and yet it's so much else besides. Director Bong Joon Ho charts how the scrappy, impoverished Kim family insinuate themselves into the lives of the Parks, who exist in the most privileged echelon of Seoul society. But that's only the start of this twisted, genre-shifting tale. Spiky social comedy morphs into Hitchcockian thriller territory, before this drama takes its most shocking turns. The contrasting rich/poor production designs are evocatively created, with the Parks' state-of-the-art super-home built from the foundations up for the film. But it's a third-act climate metaphor for the city's social divide that really steals your breath. As for that ending... wow. Brilliantly conceived and expertly executed, Parasite just stole it from Sam Mendes' First World War odyssey as my 2020 topper. 

2021 - Dune: Part One

(Honorable Mention - Spider-Man: No Way Home)

I'm not one to cry 'snub' every time awards bodies fail to give some film I love its due, but the fact that Denis Villeneuve hasn't received a Best Director nomination for either of his Dune episodes to date is a travesty - a travesty, I tell you! Described in the past as unfilmable (David Lynch's 1984 adaptation may prove or disprove that assertion, depending on your take), Frank Herbert's 1965 science-fiction epic found its perfect fit in the French-Canadian director, whose commitment to visual authenticity turned huge SF projects Arrival and Blade Runner 2049 into such arresting cinema. His Dune films to date have looked convincing in every gorgeously composed frame, with multiple worlds and weird technologies depicted as if they exist for real. The plot complexities are streamlined to render Herbert's sprawling narrative accessible, and each movie boasts a roster of fine actors at the top of their game. Plus, Villeneuve had the good fortune that composer Hans Zimmer decided on a trial separation from Christopher Nolan to create a grand, interplanetary music-scape for the Dune-iverse. Roll on the concluding Dune: Part Three in December of this year.

2022 - Top Gun: Maverick

(Honorable Mentions - The Batman; Everything, Everywhere, All At Once)

A couple of friends, having been less than enthused by Top Gun: Maverick, asked me to sell them on why it's a worthy choice for film of the year. What could I say?  There's no analysing the movie for deeper meaning - everything great about it is up there on the screen or blasting from the surround-sound speakers. What I really love about Tom Cruise's return to the TG military flight school, though, is how real it all is. With a clutch of Mission: Impossible films behind him, and a name rebuilt on doing the stunts for real, Cruise worked with director Joseph Kosinski to create a heightened and visceral action-cinema experience. They did all they could to fly viewers through the sunlit skies at Mach 10 along with the actors, the on-screen G-forces driving us deep into our luxury recliner seats. Undergoing such thrills as part of a laughing and gasping IMAX crowd felt liberating after the pandemic years. The movie was also a rattling good adventure and a superbly realised exercise in nostalgia, while providing something fresh and new. So if you came out of a screening feeling the same kind of buzz as me, that makes me happy. If not... well, I hope you found your post-Covid cinematic buzz somewhere else.

2023 - Oppenheimer

(Honorable Mentions - John Wick: Chapter 4; Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse)

I hope that Christopher Nolan never stops thinking big (and I have faith he won't). The reasons Oppenheimer turned out to be such a critical and box office success are common, I think, to all his films. The first is that every Nolan movie is a passion project. Having been given a copy of J. Robert Oppenheimer biography The Modern Prometheus at the Tenet wrap party, he immersed himself in the book and saw biopic potential in it. Secondly, the filmmaker commits to big dramatic swings. Thus, his Oppenheimer takes two alternating viewpoints - first and third person, in colour and black-and-white respectively - and shifts partway through from scientific race-against-time thriller to full-on political drama, while never losing sight of the moral conundrum at the movie's centre. Finally, he knows how to find the dynamism and flow in whatever film he's making, whether comic-book adventure, science-fiction epic, or weighty historical drama. And so his three-hour story of the so-called 'father of the atomic bomb' has a momentum that carries you from those opening raindrops on water to that final, devastating Cillian Murphy close-up in what feels like half the time. That's got to be worth a few Oscars. Say, seven?

2024 - Anora

(Honorable Mentions - Dune: Part Two; The Substance)

My introduction to filmmaker Sean Baker was 2017's The Florida Project, so I knew going into Anora the kinds of character that interested him - those struggling on the margins of American society, whether sex workers, street hustlers, or victims of extreme poverty. In the case of Anora, it's Ani (the title refers to her), an exotic dancer and escort in a Manhattan gentlemen's club who falls for Ivan, the son of a Russian oligarch. What begins as a decadent fantasy takes a twist into romantic territory, before Ivan's parents get wind of the affair and move to stop it, pushing the story into different territory altogether. If you approach Baker's award-winning film as a more raw, chaotic, and bittersweet take on Pretty Woman, you'll have some idea what to expect. Anora has wild eroticism and flashes of heightened romance, along with uncomfortably funny slapstick, ferocity, despair, poignancy, and an unforgettable Take That needle drop. It's all here in one film, and much of it (not the Take That part) is due to Mikey Madison's virtuoso, Oscar-bagging lead performance. Gal's going places. Whether or not Ani is... only watching the movie will reveal.

2025 - Sinners

(Honorable Mention - The Ballad of Wallis Island)

Ryan Coogler's Sinners is a rich and heady brew. Yes, the director cites 1996's From Dusk Till Dawn as one of his influences, but set in Jim Crow-era Mississippi and tackling issues of race, culture, and spirituality, it's entirely its own vampire-fanged beast. One year on from its lengthy run in cinemas, its sounds and images remain vivid in the memory. Michael B. Jordan passing a cigarette to his twinned self within the frame. Jack O'Connell scuttling grotesquely towards the homestead of his first victims. Miles Caton cutting loose with original blues song 'I Lied To You', while the camera weaves through space and time in one cinema's most memorable one-shots... ever. These are just a few of the film's manifold and multi-layered delights. Its tale of the Smokestack brothers and their one-night-only (but what a night), bloodsucker-besieged juke joint will stay with me a long, long time. When does a horror film become more than a horror film? When it has the vision, depth, and craft of Sinners

2026 - ?????

So that, for what it's worth, is my list. It may not stay my list - there's any number of highly praised 21st-century films I've yet to catch up with. But for now, I hope it raises a few smiles along with a few eyebrows, and provokes a bit of good-natured debate. If it doesn't suggest to you the best that modern cinema has to offer, or if you feel I need a total taste-overhaul, then your viewing recommendations will be gratefully received. Aside from that, here's to the cinematic century so far and, more importantly, to what lies ahead.

Saturday, 12 January 2019

Feature - 10 Out of 10 - Which Movies Get a Filmic Forays Top Score?

These go to eleven. Nigel Tufnell - This is Spinal Tap
'So when are you finally going to give your first 10?' a friend recently asked, concerning my reserved attitude to top-scoring on this very blog.

Last year I rated Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri and The Shape of Water as 9/10, while going so far as to present Isle of Dogs, First Man and Roma with a 9.5 apiece. Newly released The Favourite gained that latter score last week. Is begs the question 'Come on, Ed, what do you actually consider deserving of a 10?' closely followed by 'Are there actual criteria by which you're judging, or are you just winging it?' and 'Who the hell are you to pass judgement anyway sitting there typing your crap while proper creatives have devoted maybe years of their lives to producing a complex piece of cinematic art/entertainment only to have some self-appointed critic casually fling a number at it and besides when did you ever make a film, jackass?'
The response to the final one is 'Bit harsh, pal - I'm simply providing a personal viewpoint on something I love - cinema - and my ratings are precisely that, 'personal', so - you know - don't shoot me. And no, I've never made a film, I only wish I had.'

(To be honest I've never been expected to answer the third question or anything like it. That's just me being unnecessarily defensive.)
As for the first two questions, I think there are many films deserving of my 10, including in retrospect - that being a key phrase - several from last year. As for the criteria, they're not scientific, but they go something like this:

1. Level of technical accomplishment, i.e. how well the film is directed, acted, etc (obvs).

2. How I respond to it at the time, i.e. my gut reaction.

3. How well it sticks, i.e. its rewatchability/retrospect factor.


The third one is particularly important in finalising a top score. I'm instinctively reluctant to slap a 10/10 on any film after a first watch - it seems such a big statement and leaves only one direction to go on subsequent viewings. If I've scored 8 or upwards, however, it's perfectly possible that second time around  the movie's merits will impress me even more. Example - I rewatched A Quiet Place over New Year with friends and it struck me how fine this thriller is in multiple regards - tense, beautiful and moving. Maybe deserving of higher than 8.5 and a place in my 2018 Top Ten list. Oh the agonies of the conscientious reviewer... 
Point is, if either First Man or The Favourite for example hold up and reveal even more second time around (as I strongly suspect they will), then I will very gladly stamp them with a big fat 10/10. It won't mean much in the grand scheme, but it'll feel satisfying to me.

With all that in mind, here are six random films out of many possible choices, and the reasons why they get the Filmic Forays Not-Necessarily-Perfect 10. 

1. This is Spinal Tap (1984)
Oh this one is perfection. Rob Reiner's template mockumentary gets funnier on every viewing. The first time you watch this story of a Brit rock-band trying to relive former glories on an ill-fated American tour, you laugh at the obvious stuff - the band's response to their rubbish matt-black album cover, the inappropriate name of Nigel Tufnall's Mozart/Bach-inspired piano piece, the onstage Stonehenge debacle. On subsequent revisitings every throwaway line, every stumble, every bemused reaction shot becomes hilarious. The whole film heightens reality just enough to keep the humour exquisite, while the edit ensures that absolutely nothing is wasted, in what becomes a strangely touching bromance (between idiots). It's a mine of comedy gold that just keeps on delivering.

2. The Shawshank Redemption (1994)

There's a reason that Shawshank is at the top of imdb.com's Top Rated Movies. It's not necessarily 'the greatest film ever made', but it does hit the spot for a broad demographic of viewers. How good is it? Well I recall wondering, two thirds of the way through my initial watching of the movie, whether something that promised so much could actually deliver a climax to match. It did, twice. Two bravura payoffs - one air-punchingly dramatic, the other profoundly moving, combined to create one of the most satisfying film endings in the history of film endings. And all due to the painstaking craft of every scene that had gone before. This film is a paean to the best kind of hope and a love-letter to friendship. There are scores of people who claim it saved their life, for heaven's sake. Shawshank has earned its top score.
   
3. Magnolia (1999)
Paul Thomas Anderson's Magnolia is a great example of what I'm going to refer to from now on as an 'Imperfect 10'. It's one of my two favourite film projects of all time (The Lord of the Rings is the other one, thank you for asking) and it's a thing of magnificence, charting as it does the trials of ten disparate Los Angelenos over a single day. This three-hour epic of human emotion grapples with a clutch of big questions in an intense and imaginative way. Thing is, in its ambition one whole subplot gets dropped along the way and with all the drama brewing the opening half hour can become oppressively sweary-shouty, but as a whole this movie gets so much right, draws out such blistering performances and pulls off such jaw-droppingly audacious moments of drama that to give it anything less than the full compliment of points would be - frankly - wrong. (This phenomenon could also be referred to as the Apocalypse Now factor.) 

4. Shaun of the Dead (2004)
Ah Shaun. Now here's a film that I'd probably have given a good solid 8/10 on first viewing. But then you watch it again (and again, and again...) and like This is Spinal Tap you begin to relish all the tiny little visual and verbal touches that you missed first time around. How intricately structured the whole thing is, how it sustains humour and menace without compromising either, how it achieves actual emotional depth amid all the comedy-zombie mayhem. Every moment is thoughtful and creative, it's a masterclass in storytelling technique and it rises above pure genre parody to become a wonderful (and uniquely British) creation in its own right. Shaun is one of those films I'll watch if I stumble upon it on TV, even though I own the DVD. 'It's on the telly right now, so what else am I going to do? It's Edgar Wright's masterpiece!'

5. Children of Men (2006)
I include this one partly because it's my favourite Alfonso Cuaron film and a damn fine dystopian thriller, and partly to point out that where film appreciation is concerned, it's horses for courses. I once recommended Children of Men to a friend and his wife as my 2006 film of the year (a slam-dunk - one of those choices I didn't even have to think about) and they both - quote - 'hated it'. Maybe its vision of future Britain was just too bleak, but whatever had impressed me simply didn't work its dark magic for them. I recommend it undeterred, especially if you loved Cuaron's recent Roma. It bears all those same marks of cinematic craft, but used in a more dynamic way, albeit in a world where the entire human race has been rendered infertile and is staring at oblivion's slow approach. A movie of colossal technical ambition with a profound story at its centre - one that's not as hopeless as I've made it sound. But I'll let you decide between my love and my friends' hate. 

6. The Babadook (2014)
I've already explained why I admire this film both here and here, so there's little more to be said. Like Shaun of the Dead this little Australian gem demonstrates shot-by-shot mastery of film-making craft, only this time used to much more serious effect. The Babadook turns limited budget into a virtue, reminding us that vast scale is not a prerequisite for creating great cinema. It's a horror pic, yes, but (again like Shaun) it transcends genre, the sheer ingenuity of the storytelling becoming more apparent every time you return to it. So I'm properly perplexed that director Jennifer Kent's 2018 follow-up film The Nightingale hasn't been given a UK release date yet. Just saying.
??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
  

As those choices probably shows, there's no hard and fast technical rule as to why any one film makes it onto my unofficial 'favourites' list. Basically if I love a movie enough to revisit it for the sheer joy of its craft along with whatever emotion it inspires in me, it's earned that ultimate rating, And that's regardless of nitpicks or the possibility that it's aimed stratospherically high without hitting the mark in every regard (I return you again to my 'Imperfect 10' concept). 

You'll forgive me if I hold off on slapping the big One-Zero on any title after a first screening (including those on my Films of 2018 Top List), however much I appreciate it at the time. If a movie is that good, it'll more than withstand multiple viewings. Plus this system gives me an excuse to go back to some thrilling filmic places in the near future. 

Isle of Dogs, First Man, The Favourite, I'm not done with you yet...